My friend Fartacus mentioned the similarity between the tripods in Spielbergs 'War of the Worlds' and the alien queen in 'Aliens' and I thought this would be a good idea for a rambling post. Its one of those problems concept artists face. Just how do you make something appear alien? Or even just unusual and non terrestrial? Thanks to HR Geiger, there is a common perception of what a serious alien head should look like, it should be elongated, and preferably very dark. You can even find an online, step by step guide as to how to re-create this head:
The other popular type of alien head is of course the grey skinned, Roswell type, with a tiny nose and mouth and huge big black eyes, but these are not as scary so they only get used in cheaper sci fi aspiring to be 'realistic'. For the full, scare-your-pants-off experience, the common perception requires the elongated, phallic, head, preferably with a lot of teeth.
But say you want to design an alien being and you want to avoid the classic look. What do you do? It has to be recognisable in some way, but you want to make it look as 'alien' as possible. Easy, you look at the animal kingdom, find the animal which best suits your needs and then you add in the required anthropomorphic features which you wish to retain. Thats essentially how most aliens get designed. HR Geiger's first alien looked totally alien to the 1979 crowd, but if you look at it, then you see its still just a man in a suit. It has two arms and two legs, a head at the top and a fingers and toes. Yes it has a tail and spiny ridges all over, but essentially its just a scary humanoid. Its a spiky version of ET. HR Geiger used a snake skeleton as his template and then just added all the extra humanoid features. The only aliens that avoid this process of design are those which are described as being 'energy or gaseous beings' and almost every alien in the Sci fi TV universe which are actors in make up (or 'fore head of the week' as I've heard them aptly described)
In the original book 'War of the Worlds', HG Wells went the other way, he attempted to describe his Martians as being evolved humanoids. He took away many of the anthropomorphic features and left the bare essentials because his alien concept had the Martians wearing machines as bodies. An utterly cool concept for a Victorian author and one not really improved upon since. HG Wells might not have had the most 'alien' aliens, but he did have the most compelling concept I've ever seen for what an alien might actually look like, and he did it without recourse to an animal. Most of the science fiction I've ever read (and I've read a lot) has used animals or humanoids as the basis for alien concept, with spiders and insects being a firm favourite for the really unusual and HR Geiger's design being a sort of gold standard for the commercial exploitation of the whole idea. HG Wells used machines that moved with the unconsious grace and animation of bodies. He gave the 'fighting machines' three legs for stability and the 'handling machines' multiple limbs for practicality. "The Martians made and used different bodies according to their needs".
Getting back to the tripods in Spielbergs 'War of the Worlds', looking at the concept art I think they were originally meant to be closer to HG Wells vision of the machine body but some where along the way the humanoid meme crept back in. Spielbergs actual aliens became men in suits again. The fact that they are three legged doesn't change their humanoid appearance. HG Wells had described the Martians as being evolved into big heads with tentacle fingers and huge dark eyes in the front. Mollusc like. That description is echoed by the Spielberg tripods, but not by the actual aliens themselves who became pantomime variants of their own machines. Curious. I have no doubt that a scene where Tom Cruise hides from several large heads was not deemed 'cinematic' enough...
9 comments:
I still haven't read War of the Worlds, but I really should, because I know that I'll love it. Victorian sci-fi is right up my alley.
The first thing that came to mind when you posted the bottom image is Lovecraft who's also been influential in developing the shape of "monsters" in the human mind. Makes me wonder if Lovecraft was reading Wells, but since I haven't read the latter, I don't know the actual written description is similar or if it's just in the image that you posted.
"if" the actual written description is similar...
My brain is working more quickly than my fingers today.
Ahh, you must read it at once! It is without a doubt the seminal work of the genre.
I don't know how much influence Lovecraft has had. I see him as a more extreme version of Poe, and some what marginalised in the main stream perspective. Images of Cthuhlu are not uncommon, but I don't come across the wealth of interpretation that WOTW has spawned. The image you refer to is a concept painting and could be influenced by Lovecraft. The machines in the film are very similar to it. I've not seen any reference mentioned to Lovecraft in anything I've read about the film though.
On the other hand, for the horror genre, Lovecraft can't be over looked and then its a case of how much cross fertilization has taken place. Geiger never mentions Lovecraft in any of the books I've got but that doesn't mean much. Doug Chang, the concept artist who painted that particular image has done a lot of work for George Lucas and Steven Spielberg in the past but not much horrorific art. He's mostly a sci fi machine specialist
Having said all that, I do agree the image does look like a Cthuloid monster!
Hey I spawned a blog entry! (Does a little dance)
It seems aliens have been too much inspired by Giger. Even the "Grays" have. Look at the aliens in Independence Day and WotW and they're sort of traditional Grays that have been amped up on "Alien" DNA.
I suppose it makes for a more visually interesting look, what with all that big elongated phallic heads, and tentacles, and slimy surfaces, and that creepy sexual undertone. It's as if the universe is populated by giant penises.
I can only imagine what they'd do in this day in age with a big budget CGI movie with tribbles.
I agree with Cyan that the last image does have a strong Cthulhu vibe going for it. But then, so does the Flying Spaghetti Monster.
Fartacus
Don't forget Daleks (functionally similar to Wells' Martians, but with their own novel style).
There were other turn of the (last) century aliens derived from animals *and* 'evolved' Humans, such as the ones based on social insects, living inside the moon (Verne's Selinites ? or something along those lines). These spawned a whole genre of insectmen.
One thing that looks cool, but is way overworked: Giger Aliens had long heads, but later variants got this Triceratops-like frill. Now everybody has to have one.
Oleg
I read the book and thought movie versions of the tripods were perfect. Kinda scary but mostly just big and powerful. The really gave the impression of it's incredible size. I wished they would have crashed though, instead of the pilot being "injected". Oh well. Can't have everything.
You're completely right about the humanoid look. Maybe a monsterous "person" is scarier than a monsterous bear or dolphin.
I loved the tripods in Spielbergs WOTW and frankly they save the movie for me because just about everything else in the film was so removed from the original as to be worthless. I could write a very long post about the many flaws!
But thats what happens when you have to brings a 19th century novel into a the 21st century.
If it had been up to me I'd have made it in the 19th century, but thats not possible I guess when your Steven Spielberg because at that level their are serious constraints that go far beyond the aesthetic. I have no doubt that Jeff Wayne's 'War of the Worlds' (due for release this year) will address the balance, though his fighting machine design does not have the 'weight' of the Speilberg machines.
Oleg.
Yeah, I notice the 'frill' as well. Games Workshop pounced on them at once since it gave them something to work with.
Brando.
What did you think of the book?
Yes, the Games Workshop Hive Tyrant is a blatant rip off. The Warriors too. The models look great, but there's no question what they look like.
Sort of like the Imperial Guard Sentinel. George Lucas has got to be thinking, "C'mon guys. Why don't you guys just name them ATSTs?"
I liked the WOTW book just fine. It was sort of about the industrial revolution. I like the idea of books and movies with a political point, but way after their time.
Thats Games Workshop for ya. They never let a good idea go unstolen.
=)
Post a Comment